Hmmmm, I've still got a couple of episodes to go, so perhaps it gets better - but my opinion of this series is - WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO ALL MY EXPLOSIONS????
Series 3 was tedious in the extreme (apart from the very beginning and the end) and the makers said 'oops! blame it on SciFi - which was refreshingly honest; but Series 4 has been Planning Committee Galactica - alternating between pass-the-president, mystic visions and oh my god MEETINGS. I have meetings every day, they're dull; I watch TV to get away from minutes of the previous meeting and chairs' action - only to find - yes the future between the stars holds apologies from those who couldn't make it.
Maybe I'm being shallow, but I just want my explosions back.
Kudos - the writers are trying to comment on Bush's America, TWaT and Iraq; but ummm - we can see you've just changed a few names and changed Washington into a howling void devoid of civilisation (you can add your own punchlines here).
Battlestar Galactica? I keep thinking LA Law has been beamed into space and deprived of sunlight.
[And yes I'm still going through CJ withdrawal symptoms now the West Wing is over]
I watched the last three episodes last night and I thought was gerat - all the layers in the writing that certain other series I could mention keep missing.
But I can't decide about the actual mid-season finale: both because the actual manner in which they find the path to Earth seemed as hasty a tack-on from nowhere as anything Russell T Davies has attempted and because I couldn't decide what the final scene was suggesting.
Now I have to join the rest of you waiting for 2009!
In brief - and not for the first time - I'm in agreement with you, Stuart. :) Superb stuff.
I think perhaps there was just enough suggestion surrounding Starbuck's Viper to prepare us for the fact that it was going to play a role in locating Earth but quite such a crucial role does seem to make it a bit too easy. I was left utterly wowed by the break, even though like you I wasn't quite sure where it would be leading us next. But a) I was glad they didn't break it five minutes earlier ;) and b) I'm reasonably confident it won't be a massive fake regeneration 'handjob' style cheat. :)
Also, glad you're level with us now and, I hope, just as impatient and frustrated as the rest of us for the next half ;)))
On the subject of fake regeneration handjobs, someone should show Rusty the scene where Deanna tells Laura Roslin she's one of the Final Five - both so he can see how a spoof reveal like that should actually work and because he could then watch the next five minutes and maybe realise that something like that doesn't have to be a cliffhanger...
Born in Penzance in 1967. From the age of about three I was probably dreaming of writing for Doctor Who. Certainly it wasn't a case of just watching it: I'd go to bed with all sorts of adventures and story possibilities buzzing around in my head. From the age of eleven, I knew, whenever any aunts and uncles asked the "What do you want to do when you grow up?" question, the stock replies of jet pilot, train driver, astronaut were never going to be good enough for me. "I want to be a writer", I always said. And, what do you know, I am.
10 comments:
Have I mentioned that I cleverly saved the entire season to watch at once, thereby significantly lessening the period until the conclusion? :-)
Can I just add a grrrrrr, to my aaaaaargh? (Me, getting more articulate with every post :) )
It's so obvious you're a professional writer - you have such a way woth words :)
I do me best :)
Hmmmm, I've still got a couple of episodes to go, so perhaps it gets better - but my opinion of this series is - WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO ALL MY EXPLOSIONS????
Series 3 was tedious in the extreme (apart from the very beginning and the end) and the makers said 'oops! blame it on SciFi - which was refreshingly honest; but Series 4 has been Planning Committee Galactica - alternating between pass-the-president, mystic visions and oh my god MEETINGS. I have meetings every day, they're dull; I watch TV to get away from minutes of the previous meeting and chairs' action - only to find - yes the future between the stars holds apologies from those who couldn't make it.
Maybe I'm being shallow, but I just want my explosions back.
Kudos - the writers are trying to comment on Bush's America, TWaT and Iraq; but ummm - we can see you've just changed a few names and changed Washington into a howling void devoid of civilisation (you can add your own punchlines here).
Battlestar Galactica? I keep thinking LA Law has been beamed into space and deprived of sunlight.
[And yes I'm still going through CJ withdrawal symptoms now the West Wing is over]
Gosh, iCowboy, that's a bit harsh.
I watched the last three episodes last night and I thought was gerat - all the layers in the writing that certain other series I could mention keep missing.
But I can't decide about the actual mid-season finale: both because the actual manner in which they find the path to Earth seemed as hasty a tack-on from nowhere as anything Russell T Davies has attempted and because I couldn't decide what the final scene was suggesting.
Now I have to join the rest of you waiting for 2009!
In brief - and not for the first time - I'm in agreement with you, Stuart. :) Superb stuff.
I think perhaps there was just enough suggestion surrounding Starbuck's Viper to prepare us for the fact that it was going to play a role in locating Earth but quite such a crucial role does seem to make it a bit too easy. I was left utterly wowed by the break, even though like you I wasn't quite sure where it would be leading us next. But a) I was glad they didn't break it five minutes earlier ;) and b) I'm reasonably confident it won't be a massive fake regeneration 'handjob' style cheat. :)
Also, glad you're level with us now and, I hope, just as impatient and frustrated as the rest of us for the next half ;)))
On the subject of fake regeneration handjobs, someone should show Rusty the scene where Deanna tells Laura Roslin she's one of the Final Five - both so he can see how a spoof reveal like that should actually work and because he could then watch the next five minutes and maybe realise that something like that doesn't have to be a cliffhanger...
Ha, yes! Was that a great moment, or what!
Post a Comment