Sunday, April 27, 2008

Non-Probic Vent

It being the first of a two-parter, I'm being fair and reserving comment on The Sontaran Stratagem until I've seen the second episode. When I do comment it'll only be one of my mini-reviews anyway, but in the meantime, pardon me while I have a mini-rant.

Now, I realise nostalgia must play a factor, but I do have fond memories of the relationship between the Doctor and the Brigadier and despite the fact that they were at loggerheads - the scientific versus the military mind - their friendship was a special one. And here we were with the Doctor reunited with UNIT and what I'm seeing played out between David Tennant's Doctor and this brand new UNIT Colonel actually makes me angry.

It's curious and disheartening that New Who rarely provokes anything like such an active response from me - usually it leaves me pretty much in neutral. But when I think of the opportunities in terms of painting a rounded, convincing military character and establishing relations between him and the Doctor, what we got was, if you'll excuse the pun, Major Disappointment.

Poor enough that he's portrayed as a spineless non-entity who obligingly salutes Donna Nobody on demand, far far worse that the Doctor insists he doesn't want the man standing next to him because he's *wearing* a gun. The man hadn't even been given a chance to be a *character* let alone a bit of a bastard, which might at least have earned him the snub. But no, this was entirely based on the fact that the man was in the military and completely disregards the Doctor's previous regard for the Brigadier. This from the Doctor who metes out cruel and unusual punishments on aliens who happen to piss him off, who's just recently caused the deaths of 20,000 people in an effort to save the world and preserve the course of history (and who, but for Donna, wouldn't even have saved a single Roman family), and who wields his sonic screwdriver *like a gun*.

This Doctor is apparently being painted as a Lonely God. And, in case any further evidence were needed, now we have an explanation for the 'Lonely' part. And frankly, I'd grown to dislike the man already, but this was the point where I'd really had enough of him. So, any kids out there whose father happens to be an officer in the military, don't worry, it doesn't mean your daddy's evil. It's just that, no matter how much the script will insist he's 'dazzling' or 'brilliant', this particular Doctor is a self-righteous, sanctimonious prick.

Hopefully next week a Sontaran - or maybe Donna - will slap him around a bit and teach him not to be such an ass.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Apocalypse Then

You know how it is: there you are, working away in your biological warfare lab and whoops! you drop your test tube. A few days later, you travel the globe, getting your passport stamped in all sorts of exotic locales, suddenly you start to feel a bit piquey, then everyone drops dead and before you know it civilisation as we know it is wiped out in the space of a couple of weeks. Bugger.

But you see, I have to make light of it, because the scenario is so utterly chilling. And so dramatically and effectively summed up in the opening credit sequence, that Survivors barely needs a pilot episode to tell us how it all happens. It can cut pretty quickly to the grim post-Apocalyptic business of survival.

We've only just started to watch the series - we're a mere three episodes in - and I'm just hoping our DVD rental people will keep the discs coming promptly because it's, frankly, gripping stuff. And the thing is, I'm trying to recall whether I'd watched any of it before. I don't think so. Where I get a slight buzz of nostalgia is in the opening credits, and I remember it vividly - but I also remember being packed off to bed at that point (I was eight). Good thing too. Because god knows, if I'd been allowed to stay up and watch, here is a show that would surely have given me nightmares. And not the inspiring imagination-sparking type of nightmares Doctor Who used to generate.

The Doctor Who credentials are there, for sure: Terry Nation scripting, Pennant Roberts directing the first episode, Talfryn Thomas giving it some great character actor welly. And that opening sequence that inevitably reminds me of the spread of the alien plague in Doctor Who And The Silurians. Back then, this is what adults got instead of Torchwood, I guess.

If I had one gripe with it, I'd only grumble slightly at the fact that most of the central characters so far appear to be of the crisply spoken RADA set, who will probably maintain their stiff upper lips in the face of world's end but that was a feature of a lot of TV drama back then and in any case they are at least interesting characters, whose survival you find yourself very readily invested in - even Greg (Ian McCulloch) who's so adamant about not wanting to burden himself with responsibility for others. Yeah, you say that now, mate.

By curious coincidence - you know, in the sense of not being a real coincidence at all and just one I'm choosing to see for convenience' sake - we're also at this point three episodes in on the fourth season of Battlestar Galactica, that other tale of the last vestiges of humanity struggling to survive in the wake of a man-made Apocalypse. And it's that show, if anything, that gives me a degree of optimism when it comes to the question of a Survivors remake.

I'm not saying it's the model: the two scenarios are universes apart. But the grimness, the harsh choices faced, the blurred lines of morality are suggestive of the sort of things that could be explored more fully, unfettered by the strictures of 70s era broadcasting. As long as the producers remember that the story they're telling would be about the disintegration of society and, like it or not, one of the earliest things out the window would be political correctness.

They might also do well to remember that Survivors managed, as far as I can tell, to convey grimness without (so far) showing us much in the way of gore. Good composition, less decomposition, I suppose.

Thanks to Stuart for, through no fault of his own, inspiring me to finally get on and rent the series.

Saturday, April 19, 2008

Ood've Thought

A budget alien landscape. A developing sense of mystery. A simple, focused plot. And lots of running around and shooting in an old industrial complex. It's like Doctor Who all over again. All it really needed was a tweak or two here and there: less repetition of the obvious from Donna, more proactive involvement from the Doctor in the resolution, one or two fewer bad actors among the speaking extras and, of course, less Donna. But overall, I felt Planet Of The Ood was an improvement. Like the ad for the Ood at the beginning, I liked it even if it didn't make me want to go out and buy one. But so far, the series is showing a steady upward trend. It'll be a long climb from the quality abyss that was Partners In Crime, but at least it's moving in the right direction.

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Resting On Caesar's Laurels

Imagine the scene. Well-to-do head of a Roman household showing off newly purchased "works of art", the wife's worried about the expense, in walks the son clearly suffering from a hangover. At about the same time, two adventuring companions arrive in the household bringing all kinds of upheaval with them. Yes, of course, it's Asterix And The Laurel Wreath, by Goscinny and Uderzo. The "works of art" are Asterix and Obelix themselves and not the TARDIS. It's also fair to point out, it's only a book and therefore can't boast the spectacular CGI of The Fires Of Pompeii, but it's fun and I recommend it thoroughly. As soon as Doctor Who introduced us to its Roman family template, I remembered the scene with fondness after a great many years. Nuff zed.

Sunday, April 06, 2008

The Other Season 4 Premiere

Thank the gods, there were other things to watch after last night's Doctor Who. And no, I speak not of the BBC's I'd Do Anything, nothing but a fantastic metaphor for all reality TV shows, but of the opening episode of Battlestar Galactica's 4th and final season.
Technically, it started on Friday night in the US. But 'technically' also happened to have a lot to do with how we were able to watch it only a day later. Anyway, I know that to compare BSG with Doctor Who would be to compare two entirely different foodstuffs. On the other hand, watching one after the other is sort of like sitting down to a two-course meal, and we're free to be of the opinion that one course impressed us more than the other. Of course, if you're going to have a Mr Men yoghurt - high in poly-unsatisfacturates - for starters, pretty much anything is going to come off like a real treat. And it was - a hearty meal.
Ironically, after venting - albeit in a limited way, because I no longer feel inclined to waste much breath on the subject - on Doctor Who, I'm conscious that I can't in all fairness discuss BSG in any detail, because there will be plenty who won't have seen it yet. Suffice to say though, the impulse and the desire to discuss it are very much there and that in itself is some measure of the difference in impressions left on me by the two shows.
Now, any season opener comes with its share of inherent goodwill. In other words, if it's a show you've missed, its return is bound to be welcome and you're basically glad to have it back. So I freely confess, that bias was in play. (As it was for Who, despite The Last Of The Time Lords - at least, for the first few minutes.) Against that, by way of balance, season openers come burdened with expectations - and BSG managed to generate a lot of them in its closing third-season episodes - and so there's a lot riding on how they measure up.
So, what is it safe to say? There are answers to burning questions (supplied, if anything, a little too prematurely in the pre-teaser tag-line sequence), there's a wham-bam opening, there are intriguing developments and there are, inevitably, more questions, new mysteries. On the whole, the sense I had was that of having watched a long-awaited mini-movie, one that has properly refuelled my addiction and one that, crucially, delivered on its promise. Just what you want.
Now, there's room for things to go downhill from here, of course there is, but for all that this is one of those blog posts that doesn't tell you much of anything, one of the reasons it's here at all is a need I felt to type something positive. And the mere idea that things could go downhill from here sets BSG a few giant beanstalks above Who.
Still, all is not lost on the Who front. We have Up Pompeii to look forward to next week, and if David Tennant gets to do a Lurcio-style "The Prologue...", that should cheer things up in that quarter. Failing that, we should be having another helping of Battlestar for our main course, so I may not care.

Saturday, April 05, 2008

Chewing The Fat

The fat just walks away, apparently. Unfortunately, despite the claims, the gristly bits that are impossible to digest and stick in your teeth will very likely be lodged there forever. I don't think the bad taste left in my mouth after tonight's Doctor Who Season Four premiere will be going away soon. The memory of those lardy Gremlins waving from the mothership window will probably also be with me from now until the day I die.
You know, just like those memorable scenes of old - yes, it's right up there with the Sea Devils rising from the ocean that's stuck with me since childhood. Um, no. No, that's a fond inspirational image, the sort of stuff that fired my childhood imagination. All those Pilsbury Dough Munchkins parading down the street are a horrible, horrible memory that will likely leave a stain.
You'll also remember how the old Doctor Who would have these big organisations that, because of budgetary problems, only had about two guards on the payroll... back then it was perhaps forgiveable, here it's merely laughable. But then, there's no excuse for the utter tripe (ha) that was on display throughout this whole sorry business.
Don't get me wrong, there were some nice touches in the mix. But I feel no inclination to dwell on them even now, because I know those will not be the enduring memories from this experience. Nicest moment for me had to be the scene of the Doctor and Donna mouthing silently to one another through a couple of windows. Naturally, this is a vast improvement on having Catherine Tate shout her way through The Runaway Bride. Such a pity they're going back to allowing her to speak for the rest of the series.
Even a less annoying entirely silent Tate could not have saved this though. The new mangled , could-it-be-any-busier theme sets up an aggravating, negative vibe from the get-go, and after some fairly amusing shenanigans of not quite letting the Doctor and Donna meet, we're into a wholly insubstantial daftfest with a plot that might have gotten away with it in The Sarah Jane Adventures, or whatever more juvenile spin off they come up with for the CBeebies.
Fat generally suggests weight and while I understand that you couldn't do a plot like this with any kind of seriousness, this was so high in fat and yet entirely weight-free, it's something of a miracle in itself. Added to which, there is the touchier issue of whether it actually manages to be offensive to people with real weight problems. Fat is funny, fat people have always been great comedy material - look at Little & Large for goodness sake. Rusty worshippers will defend him heartily on this point and accuse anyone suggesting anything of the kind of making something out of nothing. Irrespective of that 'debate', it was at best an expensive cheap joke and I'd argue that it's Partners In Crime that made something out of nothing. Only, not very much.
Honestly, I wish it would just walk away.

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Happy Birthday, Touchstone & Viola



Far be it from me to confine my foolishness to one day in April, least of all the sentimental type. So in the interests of foolish sentimentality, I just felt like posting two pics of our kitties, Touchstone (the handsome fellow in black-and-white) and Viola (the pretty tortoiseshell princess) in rare contemplative and, crucially for photographic purposes, still mode, by way of marking their second birthday. Happy Birthday to them. Non-cat-lovers may find all this nauseating, of course, but believe me when I say it's not the intention. Merely a bonus. :)

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Dixon Of Docking Bay Three

Before Enterprise made some interesting musical choices to accompany its 'special' brand of science fiction, there was another pioneering series with a theme you could sing to - if you felt inclined. Before Life On Mars, there was a show exploring the world of policing in a different time - in this case, the future - telling stories of ordinary, everyday crime and law enforcement on a new frontier, in the light of a big blue-green lamp known as Earth.
Yes, I speak of Star Cops.
For once, I'd like to be able to talk about a show without having to mention Doctor Who, but I'm not going to be able to do that on this occasion - largely because Star Cops was the creation of Chris Boucher, the man who gave us Leela. Okay, Louise Jameson had something to do with that too. Star Cops has no leather-clad savages, however - and, actually (if I can take a brief dip in entirely shallow waters), seems to steer deliberately clear of presenting us with any attractive females whatsoever. Beauty is, of course, in the eye of the beholder, but the absence of any objects of lust for the heterosexual male) in a science fiction series of its day (1987) is noteworthy. I'm being (as well as shallow) facetious, of course, but it feels like part of the essential distinction the series is making: this is not science fiction.
At least, it's not sci-fi of the fantasy breed, like Doctor Who with its long string of attractive female companions to keep the teenage lads watching long after they've grown out of it. (And quite right too.) Despite its discernible Who pedigree - Chris Boucher (who also worked on Blake's 7 and presumably that's why he accessorises his hero with an early prototype Orac, named Box), series creator, is joined in the writing credits by Philip Martin (Vengeance On Varos) and Graeme Harper (Caves Of Androzani) takes the directing helm for four episodes - you can sense this putting as much distance between itself and 'that sort of show' as it can. And maybe this was back when TV science fiction was viewed as a bad thing.
In that context, the series scores huge points for doing what it does. Although space is very much a backdrop and efforts are taken - after 'hero' Nathan Spring's initial baptism in vacuum and vomit - to characterise it all as routine - almost mundane - it simultaneously builds a neat sci fi concept into each of its nine (there were only nine episodes all told) mysteries. And although one or two of those mysteries emerge as sub-Bergerac (notably the Philip Martin episode, This Case To Be Opened In A Million Years, which comes across as incredibly weak next to the episodes that precede it), usually it works a charm.
I say 'charm', but charm, like the 'babe factor', is - another thing that separates it from Doctor Who - just not part of the series' approach. It wants to be a bit hard - not The Sweeney hard, of course, because it envisages a more pc future than that (well, to some extent, but we'll get to that) - and it manages a certain edginess, only let down by some deficiencies in the acting department.
David Calder as Nathan Spring is sour and cynical and appears on the surface to have few redeeming qualities, but you end up liking him because he's really very good. But after him, we're obliged to move down the list as we're introduced to each member of the Star Cops staff: Trevor Cooper is dependable and entertaining as seasoned dough-boy Brit-cop, Colin Devis; Linda Newton is variable as Pal Kenzie, Aussie WPC from the seedier side of Ramsey Street; Erick Ray Evans is, presumably, the best American they could afford as David Theroux; Sayo Inaba is rather pitiful as meek Japanese medical examiner Anna Shoun.
Still, therein lies half of the series' concerted efforts to paint the brand new Space Age as an international arena and it's sadly more successful in that regard than the other prong of that campaign: namely, an apparent game of Spot This Week's National Stereotype played from episode to episode. A good number of the stories, even the stronger ones, seem to concern themselves with one key nationality and it's a little unfortunate that you get a sequence that goes something like: Russians are spies, Americans are paranoid, Italians are Mafia, Arabs are fanatics. Now, to be fair, in the case of the Arabs, they made the powerful influential Arab a woman and she is the victim who has her unborn children (well, embryos) 'kidnapped'. But her response is to abduct the brother (well, clone) of the perpetrator and threaten to cut off his hand, partly because the man is a pianist and partly because that is, of course, what Arabs do.
It's unfortunate elements like that which, more than the fx, date the series and demote it to a rank somewhat lower than it would otherwise deserve. It's a shame, because the fx are - apart from a few dubious attempts to convince us of weightlessness (in which the glimpse of a string might persuade you you've switched over to some Gerry Anderson production, but is by no means the worst offence) - generally pretty good for the time and budget and sometimes stunning. (Examples of the stunning fx would *not* include a moon buggy, which a) they're obviously fond of b) is clearly a model and c) is rendered even more model-like and vaguely comical by the - again, curious - choice of music selected to accompany its rovings across the lunar landscape.) Add to that the fact that, occasionally, the stories show glimmers of being ahead of their time and even prophetic (intelligent listening systems, terrorists and (space) plane hijacks in Intelligent Listening For Beginners) and it's even more disappointing when you encounter elements that belong in the past (the Cold War still very much alive) and that, as a result, undermine much of what's been done to paint a convincing vision of the near-ish future.
All in all then, this is one I'd recommend for a watch - or rewatch - not only because there are only nine episodes, but because there's something worthy to be had from the experience and, for the moment, I can't think of another show that has made anything like such a brave foray into this area. (And no, Space Precinct doesn't count.) Again, it's down to a leap of imagination, but a similar attempt made today - with a similar degree of courage on the part of the producers, along with a more mature, contemporary approach to the realities of life on Earth as well as life 'out there' - could furnish us with something remarkable. On the other hand, people who like cop shows prefer to take their detective mysteries seriously, and once you transfer the action to a space station or the Moon, that makes it impossible for some - and you'd get a series that would probably only last for nine episodes or so. Possibly, that's what happened with Star Cops.
But short and sweet though it was, I can guarantee you, if you watch it on DVD within a short space of time, you will have its theme song firmly lodged in your brain.
It's actually nowhere near as bland as the Enterprise theme and it's by Justin Hayward, an actual somebody, and it's even pleasant - if a touch incongruous - the first time you hear it. Approach with caution, all the same.

Friday, March 07, 2008

Puffin Released Into The Wild

So March is already upon us and as I mentioned before, I have this pseudonymous children's book due out this month. The exact release date had slipped my mind - things do that when you're my age (yes, it starts early) - but I was reminded yesterday, by Stuart (who gets another name drop in the space of two blog posts - but then he deserves it, he's gone and ordered his copy) that the book is now out. Fright Night: The Shrieking Stones, allegedly by Steve Rogers but actually by yours truly. Go buy your copy now and who knows, maybe you'll get a mention here on my blog. Of course, that might be under an umbrella name of, say, "all the wonderful people who rushed out and bought my book", but imagine if at the end of movies they credited every person who watched them individually. That would just be madness. As an alternative, feel free to post comments here if/when you get a chance to read it.

Anyway, I've had a chance to read the finished article myself and I can recommend it. But then, of course, I would say that. On the other hand, I'll say it even louder when it's my name on the cover! :)

Thursday, February 21, 2008

Times Two

Time flies. Time waits for no man. Time, gentlemen, please. Yes, 'Time' carries great and varied significance to us all. Once upon a time, if said with sufficient weight, that single word could trigger a barrage of images of clocks and watches, accompanied by the chimes and bongs and tick-tick-tick of many a timepiece. Of course, that was usually only on Pipkins, but still. Meanwhile, on Doctor Who, for some reason, the inclusion of the word 'Time' in a title came to be roughly synonymous with 'not very good'.

The ~ Monster, The Invasion Of ~ , ~lash, Trial Of A ~ Lord, ~ And The Rani, whole segments of The Key To ~ , every excruciating second of Dimensions In ~. And the tradition even continues today, with Last Of The ~ Lords.

So what was I doing buying and then, to exacerbate matters, *watching* The ~ Meddler and The ~ Warrior. Both, in quick succession, I might add. Glutton for punishment?

Actually, no. I had positive memories of each of these from the first time I'd seen them and, in the ~ honoured fashion of any Who fan armed with fresh DVD purchases, wanted to revisit them and test those memories against the reality. And I'm happy to say, both passed. One with flying colours, one with flying, er, black and white.

In terms of viewing one story after another, they're a surprisingly good pairing. They're both fun romps, both bringing in new companions as TARDIS stowaways and both are what's known in the Doctor Who language as pseudo-historicals - light on the history, heavy on the pseudo - featuring anachronistic travelers tampering with the fragile course of human history - both by tipping the balance in a conflict with supplies of advanced weaponry. One opts for an atomic bazooka, one arms the temporal natives with breech-loading rifles. One ends his story stranded in his chosen time zone, the other begins his story stranded in a time that's not best-suited to his purpose. The Meddler's ambitions are central and large-scale, while the Warrior, fairly naturally, has other priorities and for him meddling, as a means to an ulterior end, is pretty much a sideline.

Now, in the case of The ~ Meddler, it so happened that Stuart, who's practically a one-man board of certification when it comes to assessing what's good and bad in Doctor Who, had recently received his copy and had posted a review on his blog shortly after I'd watched it myself. It's a very good review and I'd be afraid of accidental plagiarism if I just went ahead and agreed with him. All the same, I do agree with him and you'd probably be as well to go and read his review while I make some effort to express much the same views in my own words.
One area in which The ~ Meddler scores, of course, is that it's the first of its kind. In Who, at least, it's inventing the pseudo-historical. And I know Stuart remarked on this, but I watched it very much into the mindset of what it must have been like for contemporary viewers encountering this phenomenon for the first time. The Hartnell era up to that point would have braced them for historicals, so the discovery of the gramophone in the monastery must have been a real "What the - !" moment and then you get the major excitement of an end-of-episode reveal that the Monk HAS A TARDIS!!! As Douglas Adams might have put it, you might think space is big, but this was REALLY BIG. It's a shame that the Doctor meeting with others of his own race (note, not Time Lords at this stage) became almost routine in later years and especially in the books. Here it's fresh and new and thrilling - and playful.

It's in great part down to the casting, with pre-Carry On Peter Butterworth putting in a warmly comic performance as the Monk, and there's humour aplenty in the script, with the Doctor clearly entertained by the notion of running into one of his own - even if the chap is a confounded scoundrel. The Monk does make a notional comeback in The Daleks Masterplan, so that's some proof of his deserved popularity at the time - but it's interesting to note that he's one of those characters, a bit like the Ice Warriors, saddled with a name and identity entirely based on his first appearance. I mean, presumably, this fellow could have - if you'll forgive the pun - change his habit to return as something other than 'the Monk'.

Some of the supporting cast aren't, er, up to Butterworth's standard, shall we say, but for one thing fight sequences in such antiquated Who were rarely up to scratch and if, on top of that, you're going to ask your Vikings to act as though they're tanked up on mead, then really you're raising the bar a tad too high. It's comforting to know, though, that back in those days the Doctor, so well regarded by so many children, could be seen to enjoy a jar or two. Who knows, maybe there were floods of complaints.

What might have caused complaint, although in all probability - like the mead-guzzling Doctor - it was looked over as entirely innocent, is the implicit rape. Edith (Alethea Charlton) is attacked by said drunken Vikings and - at one point, you think - left for dead. Then later her hubby is hovering over her demanding, understandably, to know "Who did this?" She's not been killed and you have to assume she wasn't mugged for any cash she might have been carrying. And in any case you don't have to be Barbara Wright - i.e. a history teacher - to know what drunken Vikings are (in)famous for. It's only an interpretation, but an unwelcome and inescapable intrusion on what is, essentially, as I say, a fun romp. The title The ~ Meddler characterises the story well, 'meddling' being something we're not supposed to take too seriously - and harsher realities don't sit well with that.

But really that's a minor glitch and it's really not down to anything actually presented on screen. Just a product, I suppose, of watching it in a 'more informed age'. Anyway, the moment of discomfort soon passes and we can get back to enjoying the interplay between the two (Not Yet) Time Lords as much as Hartnell appears to be.

And, since we mention Barbara - she's not in this one. She and Ian returned home in a Dalek time capsule at the end of the previous story. And the TARDIS crew is now made up of Maureen O'Brien as wide-eyed and earnest, but quite sweet Vicki and Peter Purves surprisingly good as Steven, doing his best to overcome the fact that his character makes for a fairly unconvincing space pilot.

The ending's a little rushed and not as tidy as it could be. (I had thought the story left a spare atomic bazooka on the clifftop, for instance, but according to Stuart I'd missed a line from the Doctor stating that they still had a bit of clearing up to do. But on the plus side that led to a little joke about how all Doctor Who stories could, in theory, be ended that way - so nothing was lost.) But the trick the Doctor plays with the Monk's TARDIS is inventive and satisfactory, and represents an early bit of exploration of the nature of TARDIS technology. The sort of thing that would doubtless spawn a zillion fan theories, but we mustn't hold that against it.

Overall then this succeeds with whimsical charm by the flagon-ful and earns special credit for introducing us to certain concepts entirely new to the series at the time, not least of which was a new brand of Doctor Who story.

A brand which, he segued nicely, was to see some notable service in the Troughton era (e.g. The Abominable Snowmen, The Evil Of The Daleks) before returning to form the basis of just the one story in the Pertwee era: yes, The ~ Warrior.

Being of a story type already established then, The ~ Warrior is hardly as ground-breaking but it's all played with a similar sense of fun, along with the dash and flair of the Pertwee era. The humour is sharper, offering a veritable medieval banquet of great dialogue as well as priceless moments like the Sontaran Warrior claiming the Earth and its satellites for the Sontaran Empire. As surely the first race to plant a flag on Terran soil, the idea of the Sontarans later securing the services of a Megaran solicitor and endeavouring to assert their claim through the intergalactic courts is just too tempting.As our first introduction to Sontarans, it works a treat - and, through Bob Holmes' gift for one-or-two-line world-building, we learn a few choice details about them, including their 'endless war' with the Rutans and the fact that they can 'breed' like militaristic rabbits. Clones or no, they're not all the same, as later shows will prove - and while they're well on their way to looking - and sounding - rubbish in The Invasion Of ~, by the time The Two Doctors comes around, they've completed that journey. But here, Linx looks fab and Kevin Lindsay really puts some (figurative) spittle into his portrayal of this alien soldier, making this space toad very much of the venomous kind. Even if, rather like the Monk, the Sontarans' return appearances (The Sontaran Experiment aside) are a bit wanting, you can immediately appreciate the potential for a comeback. (Sadly though, we never get to see this horrible Humpty riding into battle on horseback - a missed opportunity there.)

As well as this new alien foe, the story, as has been mentioned, also introduces us to a new companion. Not just any companion either, but Sarah Jane Smith. Lis Sladen is finding her feet in the role here, but she's given plenty to work with and the gutsy way in which she brings feminism to Olde Englande and tackles head-on what she takes for a bunch of medieval reenactment freaks is superb and funny. As is the way her suspicions of the Doctor inspire her to launch a 'commando raid' to capture him on behalf of the 'good guys'.

And 'good guys' and 'bad guys' are appropriate terms. Although the timelines are under threat from the Sontaran's interference, this story concerns itself even less with actual history than The ~ Meddler, focusing on a localised feud and cracking on with an adventure that probably owes a little bit to a quick skim through Ivanhoe. It's let down here and there - like The ~ Meddler before it - by a few extras who seem to have been given lines by mistake and maybe we can blame the mead again, but their acting prowess appears to indicate that they may indeed have been medieval reenactment freaks and not professional actors at all.

Luckily, they're offset by that brilliant (Bob) Holmesian dialogue and some truly hearty performances from David Daker as Irongron and John J Carney as his thick-as-a-brick lieutenant, Bloodaxe. There's also Alan Rowe - seen recently - by me anyway - in Horror Of Fang Rock and of course, dear old Dot Cotton, June Brown, in the days long before Who producers thought it was a 'brilliant idea' to include guest stars from Eastenders. In the days, in fact, before Eastenders. For those of us who know her as Dot Cotton, it's a little unsettling at first, but once you get used to her you realise she's doing a grand job, playing a sort of good-hearted Lady Macbeth to Alan Rowe's rather ineffectual Edward Of Wessex.

It also features Boba Fett, back when he was only trained in bow and arrow. Jeremy Bulloch (who continued his archery antics in Robin Of Sherwood, I believe). Hal The Archer is not the strongest of Bob Holmes' characters, it must be said, but he's there to act as representative of the dozen men Wessex is supposed to have at his command and to deliver that final fatal blow to poor old Linx's probic vent. By this stage, it being a Pertwee story, the Doctor has been more than involved and instrumental in a successful resolution, that it's kind of fitting that the actual slaying of the enemy is handed to this supporting character. So the ending, while a bit rushed, is fairly satisfactory.

The main disappointments, I found, were in the robot knight that Linx manufactures for Irongron - a fault of being made in a time when stiff and jerky were the only modes of movement available to robots - and some of the effects. The shot of the Sontaran spaceship, for example, as seen through a window and the 'magic' of CSO, plus the shot of generic masonry being blasted to stand in for the blowing up of an entire wing of a castle. However, that said, don't be tempted - as I was - to go back and see what the CGI wizards have done for the DVD release. The Sontaran ship crashing to Earth is nice enough, but is then completely at odds with the remainder of the production, while the castle gateway belching flame is at least as pitiful as the old masonry shot and is one of those examples of bad CGI that make you cringe and wish they had asked the Blue Peter team (Purves, perhaps?) to rustle up something in papier mache instead.

But never mind. The show stands up well enough without these flashy gimmicks. Meddler and Warrior make such a great pair - which is not to say the Monk should team up with the Sontarans (although... ) - I am not going to conclude this blog review by choosing between them. I'm just going to celebrate the fact that two stories that stood so many years apart can, in this magical age of the DVD, can stand side by side. Although at the same time, I'm happy to say, there are actually a fair few stories between them on my shelves.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

ER Closure

How do you quit a soap? If we're talking the Imperial Leather, Dove or carbolic variety, then the answer's simple: quit bothering about personal hygiene. But if it's the TV brand, it's not that easy. They're this organic, living world in which we freely immerse ourselves, hoping to follow the trials, tribulations and triumphs of people for whom we're prepared to set aside, for example, 45 minutes per week, 22 weeks a year from Pilot to - presumably, if it ever gets to that stage - final curtain.

Shows like The West Wing help us out by having an effective set term built in: after Bartlett's maximum two terms, it would be difficult to imagine many continuing to watch after the cast being replaced wholesale. Now, on that one, I've yet to reach the end, but I know there is a last episode and I'm sure I'll feel an overall sense of satisfaction, not to say achievement, when I get there. But, as undoubtedly brilliant as The West Wing is, it will never quite compete with ER. Those White House bods have earned my respect, whereas the staff at Cook County General won my affections.

There have been so many characters, over the years, I've absolutely loved. Even the ones I hated - because ER always had a gift for showing us the human side of even the Weavers and the Romanos of its world. Yes, some of that love was of the romantic persuasion, but if a hospital is going to include the likes of Susan Lewis, Carol Hathaway, Jeannie Boulet, Lucy Knight, Abby Lockhart, Deb Chen and Elisabeth Corday on its staff then I - a sensitive soul who fell in love with Sarah Jane Smith at the tender age of seven - can scarcely be blamed for growing similarly fond of some of its medical professionals. And alongside that there was always the best-friend, buddy, uncle, mentor, nothing-remotely-gay-about-it-honest love for some of the male medicos - principally Carter, Pratt and, of course, Mark Green.

But the steady ebb and flow of characters is carefully managed so that, some little time before one of your favourites departs (whether as a result of marriage, the need to be with a new born niece or, quite frankly, a brutal stabbing) steps have usually been taken to introduce a new rising star with which to hook your interest and soften the blow. Like Abby with her alcoholism, there's no real ideal time to quit.

But it's that last fellow in that list, Mark, funnily enough, who provides me with an answer to my question: how do you quit a soap?

Because, while I've been faithfully following the latest season (is it really 14 now?), I've also been catching up on a rewatch of the first 8 seasons on DVD. That half-marathon, as it were, concluded yesterday with episode 21 of Season 8, On The Beach. I'm not going to say what happens in it - everyone probably knows - but it made me blub the first time and it managed to do the same without the slightest difficulty this second time around.

There was another episode after that, Lockdown, but that's a big season cliffhanger and at the end of On The Beach I arrived at a decision. Or a conclusion, you could say.

No more ER for me.

You could argue that, perhaps, it's one I should have arrived at on the first viewing. But I think you'd be wrong. I don't regret continuing to watch after that point: the show still had plenty of good - nay, superlative - drama to offer after that point. *But* it did begin to drop the ball and, particularly, mishandle certain characters in Season 10 - and that, to me, was more disappointing than a character's departure. And slowly but surely as the series rolled into its 13th and 14th seasons, I was getting a sense that one of us - either the show or me - was going through the motions. Watching the earlier shows on DVD while the new series was still unfolding finally brought the contrast home to me.

I'm watching the lives of these mostly new characters play out and I realise, as much as I still *like* some of them - Pratt, Neela, Abby - I find I don't really care about them. There's a warmth, a dynamism, a chemistry missing that, irrespective of the still-high standards the production maintains, gives me a sense of treading water. Which, when a thing used to be as good and thoroughly addictive as ER, is as close to sinking as you want it to get.

Now in the past, it's fair to say I have waxed, if not lyrical, then a fair bit about ER. Far less so than I've harped on about Doctor Who, but that's no reliable measure of where those shows place in my affections. On a purely personal note, I remember I began watching ER when my Dad was away on business the Wednesday night it started and my Mum invited me over for company and we looked for something to watch on the telly. And although my Dad was only away a couple of other Wednesdays after that, those midweek visits of mine became something of a ritual. And an entirely welcome one at that. I can't quite remember now how long that went on, but of course I continued watching in any case for all those characters I mentioned - and a few more besides. And it's only in the last two years - since, incidentally, they dropped the theme music, with its distinctive siren song opening - that I've wondered when I should think about giving up the habit.

My answer then: pick a character and follow the course of their life through to their departure. If I'd picked Susan at the start, my fanhood (is that a word?) would have lasted all of two and a half years. If I'd picked Carol or Doug, then I'd have stayed faithful for six. But the fact is, although it's easier to say in retrospect, I think if you had to pick a single character out of all of them, I'd have still opted for Mark Green. He was such an anchor to the whole team, in the midst of all the chaos. So, even though it's on a second viewing and even though I've actually watched considerably past that point, it's his departure - on DVD - that marks (ha) my own very fond farewell to the series at long, long last.

And, heck, with those discs snugly at home on their own shelf - eight seasons happened to fit *perfectly* - I can always go back and revisit any of the gang from Series 1 to 8 any time I like. And that's where all of my best medically trained friends can be found.

Apart from a couple of friends who completed their first aid course last week. Well done them.

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Rocky Horror

Graham Williams comes in for a lot of stick from me, largely because he was the producer who first showed me just how rubbish Doctor Who could really be. Now, it's not his fault that I happened to be growing up at the time - and, probably, waking up to some of the show's general shortcomings - but he is at least in part to blame for the fact that, as I was growing up, Doctor Who was travelling in the opposite direction. That said, for all his Underworlds, Nimons and Creature(s) From The Pit, he was also the producer in residence at the time of The Horror Of Fang Rock.

It is, frankly, superlative Doctor Who. Not bad for a rush job from Terrance Dicks.

Uncle Terrance had originally submitted a vampire story, but Auntie Beeb was already doing Dracula and didn’t want another set of monsters baring fangs in competition, so that was set aside for a later date and eventually became State Of Decay. But it’s easy to see how this one’s title might have come about.

So, no vampires. But what it has instead is such a near perfect mix of sf horror ingredients it’s almost as though Terrance has a recipe book to hand.

Now, I talked before about how much Planet Of Evil must have influenced Drift, but that was something to which I'd only cottoned on while watching it the other day, whereas at the time of writing the book I consciously looked to Fang Rock as my 'role model', so to speak.

It has the isolated setting (a lighthouse! - and I say this without any trace of a pun - how brilliant is that!), the nicely drawn characters getting killed off one by one, the lurking horror, atmosphere by the bucketload and, not entirely unrelated to said atmosphere, the weather. It also has Tom at his most sombre and it's really this performance that most informed my characterisation of him in the novel. As in Pyramids, he’s bordering on harsh at times in his dealings with the supporting characters, as he gets on with the serious business of defeating the alien menace. As though he is very much there at the heart of the darkness in this story, along with the alien he’s hunting – as it hunts everybody else. There are softer shades from Tom as well, like the way he tells Leela that Skinsale (Alan Rowe) “died with honour”, when that’s a fairly generous colouration of the truth, but he’s wonderfully alien – remote and removed from us mere humans, and yet capable of warmth and concerned to save us all the same.

According to director, Paddy Russell (who also helmed Pyramids), Tom wasn’t happy with the script, but if this moody Doctor is evidence of that, then Tom Baker should have been handed “rubbish” like this every time. Maybe he was sulking because he’d wanted to do the vampire story too, but whatever’s going on behind the scenes, something’s working. Heck, apparently he wasn’t getting on with Louise Jameson either, and yet the on-screen between-character dynamic is worthy of the best comedy double-act. And it’s worth noting that there is room for humour – somehow - in all the creepy, suspenseful pervading gloom. It’s simply not permitted to rule, as seemed to characterise later Williams’ adventures.

Given the challenges in production, it’s all pretty effective, visually speaking, with only what amount to minor quibbles to prove that, no matter how good it might be otherwise, this is in fact a Doctor Who story and hence subject to the same budget limitations as every other episode. But to be honest, despite a few telltale CSO-type outlines, an obviously *model* boat and a glowing spotlight for an alien mothership, really the team worked wonders. Of course the fog and the menacingly economic lighting, as well as ladling on the atmosphere, no doubt help cover a multitude of sins. But if such elements can serve a story visually as well as narratively, then pile it on, I say.

The creature itself, the Rutan scout, is a blob with tentacles and, like many a Doctor Who monster, could have done with having a bob or two more spent on it, but the jellyfish configuration is wholly in keeping with the marine setting and, who knows, maybe it’s just me, but I didn’t find it anywhere near poor enough to interfere with my enjoyment of the story. And the fan in me appreciated the tie-in with the Sontarans, another little sprinkle of world-building on the notion of a coherent Who universe like glitter on a home-made Christmas card.

There are a few moments when certain actors let the side down: John Abbott (Vince) blubbing “Oh no” a tad pathetically at the discovery of the first death, some of Annette Woollett(Adelaide)’s histrionics, for example. But on the plus side, Leela (who positively shines in this one – notable highlights: threatening especially aggravating wreck survivors with a knife, popping down the stairs for a quick gloat over her fallen Rutan foe, to name but a couple) gets to slap her and the supporting cast are pretty dependable in the main, even if (again harking back to Pyramids) there are no Bernard Archards or Michael Sheards. There is, I think, a curious continuity glitch when it appears that two characters must have passed the Doctor and Leela on the stairs without either of them noticing, but without an actual plan of where each room is situated on the stairs, I couldn’t swear to that with a hundred percent certainty. Although I guess I could go back and rewatch it again soon.

When a Doctor Who is this good, it can be sure of getting a rewatch more than once. Of course, on the other hand, it can also be fairly sure its flaws and glitches will be entirely forgiven. So, perhaps instead of reporting on possible continuity hiccups, I should be apologising to Graham Williams. So, here it is: I’m sorry, Graham.

Now, in due course, at the appropriate juncture and in the fullness of time, maybe he might in turn apologise to me. For Underworld, The Creature From The Pit, The Horns Of Nimon…

But I don’t know. Maybe The Horror Of Fang Rock makes up for all those put together.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Who's Afraid Of Gabriel Woolf?

Forgive the obvious header, but - frankly - I was. Not that I knew the man's name when I was eight. To me, he was just the almighty Sutekh The Destroyer and so scary and inspiring a villain was he, I would end up imitating him in the playground - at least as much as the Daleks. The jokes about Sutekh & Sweep came later. It's a great performance from behind a mask to rival Omega's, that voice, with its almost seductive resonance, speaks chilling volumes of a demonic all-powerful alien being tormented by thousands of years of imprisonment . There's a very good reason the current production team asked this man back to play the Devil in The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit and that reason was and is Sutekh.

He is also one of the two things - no, three. He is one of the three - four things. But heck, I'm in danger of going all Spanish Inquisition here, because as I reflect back on this adventure I'm reminded of another reason to like it - and another. So I'll just limit myself to a manageable handful and say, Sutekh is one of the *four* things that carry this story and help it stand up, if not actually out. Before that, what's wrong with it and why does it need help standing up?

As with Planet Of Evil, Pyramids Of Mars is another Who story with that 'Old, new, borrowed, blue' combination and the borrowing is similarly centred on a classic horror source.
Only in this case, it's The Mummy, of course, and in giving it such a thorough SF treatment it endeavours to turn the whole thing on its head. And you can't do that with pyramids without a little instability creeping in.

It's a bit wobbly. And I'm not talking about the sets - it's the premise. While I get that the Osirans were a decent bunch, resistant to the idea of executing this serial planet killer, for a super advanced race they leave a few too many loopholes to allow for his escape. This isn't Norman Stanley Fletcher, you fools! This is Sutekh, Set, who exterminates all life wherever he finds it. All right, part of the problem lies in - once again - over-reaching ambition, because the traps, locks and puzzles in place within the eponymous (note, singular) Pyramid of Mars - which Sarah rightly compares to the City of the Exxilons (Death To The Daleks) - aren't up to much. Of course, even if we set aside the question of why they're in place at all, the mechanisms ideally ought to have been beyond us mere mortals. But they're not: they're blessedly simple.

And, paradoxically, for such a race with such a sense of honour and decency, a bit cruel - entirely unable to discriminate between innocents and the servants of Sutekh, and ready to dispose of Sarah if the Doctor can't solve a simple riddle. The swines.

I know, I'm biased. Sarah's lovely. She shines in this too, the chemistry between Lis and Tom still on a high, with some brilliant dialogue ("Sweaty gelignite... highly unstable... one good sneeze might set it off... Any sign of detonators?... "No. Maybe he sneezed." Etc.) and all manner of magic moments. Oddly though, this is a story in which her character is both well-used and at times poorly used. Never mind all the standard victim stuff - that's par for the companion course - but she's suddenly a crack shot with a rifle, which is simultaneously a good thing, from the strong, independent female point of view but a thoughtless touch, from the where the heck in her background did she pick up that skill perspective. According to Lis Sladen, she suggested that Sarah fumbles on the first shot and that would have made a bit more sense, but she was overruled by director, Paddy Russell.

Still, speaking of not making sense, there's another 'Huh?' moment for Sarah early on, where she swans into the control room having picked out a lovely Edwardian dress (that, apparently, used to belong to Victoria) and suddenly, WHOOMF!, the TARDIS, instead of conveying them to UNIT HQ on contemporary Earth, is knocked off-course to materialise in... Edwardian England. What're the chances. Or does the TARDIS suddenly operate like the costume shop in Mr Benn?
Never mind, we forgive Sarah a lot. She's lovely, did I mention. She's also part of what sells this story, despite its flaws. Because, with a lot of running around in the early stages, being chased by shambling Osiran servitors, it would have been all too easy to mistake this for a Scooby Doo escapade - if it wasn't for the meddling Time Lord and his companion.

There's tremendous humour, but Sarah and the Doctor are taking the menace very seriously. Tom, especially, is superbly gloomy - harsh, even, when dealing with the well-meaning, bumblesome Lawrence (Michael Sheard) and practically biting the poor man's head off for being too trusting of his undead brother, Marcus Scarman. Marcus Scarman, by the way, such a great name for a villain it's worth repeating and played to Boriskarloffish perfection by Bernard Archard. In fact, the supporting cast on the whole are rather good, lending proceedings that all-important conviction I (probably) keep harping on about. Add to that the agonies in which the Doctor writhes at the feet of Sutekh, from one flash of those eyes delivered with a snake-like hiss, and an effective portrait is painted of a truly dominant figure, someone to be feared.

The narrative plays a little trick too, at one point, delivering Sarah to an alternative 1980 and treating us to a rare glimpse of the results if the Doctor didn't interfere. At a time when the Doctor's control of the TARDIS is erratic, it does rely on what would seem to be a bit of precision piloting, but it's ultimately a worthwhile side trip that serves the story well. (I'm reminded that, in a comparable way, in my very own Emotional Chemistry, companion Fitz is treated to a vision of a scorched Earth.) Nothing like a good visual to reinforces the gravity of the situation and more effective than merely stating that, if released, Sutekh will turn the Earth into a blasted wasteland.

The story needs those reactions and the 'what if' perspective because, dark as it is, in terms of all the grim death being handed out everywhere, to be properly effective in the horror stakes it could have done with being darker. Those chases through the woods take place in daylight, for instance, and the house interior, although treating us to the sort of beautiful period detail we expect from the BBC, isn't nearly shadowy enough. Of course, they would have known Brain Of Morbius was coming up, and they probably wanted to save most of their actual darkness for that. But it leaves this one a bit wanting for atmosphere at times.

In the meantime, the lighting here at least gives us a good look at the Mummies themselves and, for all that they only had to be men in bandages, there's some nice design work in evidence on those. The shallow craters to invest them with the merest suggestion of a face, those huge barrel chests letting us know there's a framework under there. That framework, when unbandaged, looks flimsy, but on the other hand these are supposed to be super high tech, so why shouldn't they be built as incredibly light as they are strong.

They're a serviceable metaphor for the story, as it happens. Peel away the layers to reveal the structure underneath and you'd never believe they'd stand up, let alone have the clout they do. But somehow the whole package, in its quintessential and colourful Doctor Who wrapping, is fairly convincing and testament to that winning 'formula' of 'old, new, borrowed, blue'.

Even if those Mummies shamble past the winning post, rather than run flat out.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Something Borrowed This Way Comes

Whenever asked that ripe and difficult question, “What makes a great Doctor Who story?”, I always opt for that tried and tested principle of “Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue.” Where the blue can, of course, be a glib reference to the TARDIS or – more importantly, because the TARDIS itself is not an essential ingredient, except (generally) as a vehicle to transport us to adventure - a quality of mood or atmosphere. Or both, why not. In any case, not ‘blue’ in the sense that Torchwood would have you believe.

Watching Planet Of Evil on DVD, I can’t help but think that this answer of mine must have had its roots in my having grown up in what – if you feel like poking certain sectors of Doctor Who fandom and watching them jump – you might call the “Golden Age”. One of the commentators on the extras refer to this Hinchcliffe era as such, but he’s not ‘trolling’ – he firmly believes it. And why shouldn’t he: he worked on the show in that era and one of the other essential ingredients, I believe, of a great Doctor Who story is a conviction on the part of the writers, producers and pretty much everyone involved in what they are doing. (If you’re in it to piss about and have a laugh – see Graham Williams – then something’s missing.) Still, the key point here is that any “Golden Age” is bound to be measured subjectively.

For some it will be Williams, for some it will be JNT, for many in years to come it will be Rusty. Even though to me they might seem like the sort of people who think Invisible Touch was the best record Genesis ever made. And, in the event that any of them ever read this blog, they would likely snort derisively at everything I have to say. But, heck, what are blogs for? On a Who mailing list I could just randomly insert the words "Golden Age" and could fairly safely guarantee that nobody would read the rest of the post. Here, I can throw the words around liberally and do a little dance like the old guy who gleefully chants "Jehovah!" in Monty Python’s Life Of Brian.

But that would just be giving in to my wicked side.

Instead, I think I’d best just get back to the topic at hand, trusting that, courtesy of my long-winded introduction, now you, the reader, are as conscious as I am that any views I have to offer on a Who story from the mid-Pertwee to mid-Baker era will come with a degree of bias. Not an unshakeable bias – a few stories (e.g. Claws Of Axos) have not been as good as I remembered. While there have also been those, like Robot, that have struck me as a good deal better than I recalled from a previous rewatch. Swings and roundabouts.

The documentaries on The Planet Of Evil DVD seem to spend a lot of time focusing on how heavily this story rips off Jekyll & Hyde, but somehow I doubt Robert Louis Stevenson is turning in his grave. For one thing, it also nicks shamelessly from Forbidden Planet, but that’s a good movie to ‘plagiarise’ and that in turn borrows from The Tempest, so no big deal. For another, SF borrowing from classic stories is something of a given and Doctor Who has always been a repeat offender in that respect, and with The Mummy and Frankenstein to follow in this season, this particular era could be regarded as something of a creative kleptomaniac. But it tends to half-inch things with the endearing impudence of some sort of Artful Dodger – and then goes on to craft its stolen goods into something unique. Like setting a gem in a different trinket, with a charm and character all its own.

Here, Louis Marks conspires with Robert Holmes and they’re such shameless tea-leaves they haven’t even bothered to file the numbers off. It’s patently clear where all the bits came from: Sorenson even concocts an 'anti-quark serum', so that he can be seen imbibing a smoking brew, as he undergoes the Jekyll-Hyde transformation in front of a mirror.

The result is a story that’s not brilliant or genius but all those classic elements that have fallen off the back of a lorry have nevertheless been blended into something original. And if the central aim was to produce a sci-fi retelling of Jekyll and Hyde, then it’s definitely a story of opposites. Matter and anti-matter, Man and Anti-Man, film on an Ealing sound stage and video in the studio.

Aye, there’s the rub. The combination of camera work and design on Zeta Minor’s jungle is entirely worthy of the award for which Hinchcliffe apparently recommended Roger Murray-Leach. You want a wholly convincing alien environment in which to immerse your actors and your audience? You want it all for a few hundred quid? Roger’s your man. And David Maloney (who does love his freeze-frame cliffhangers) does a grand job of adding to the depth and believability of this simultaneously dark and colourful world. I love it now at least as much as it impressed me as a kid.

Against that, in its efforts to keep the narrative moving, the story doesn’t make nearly enough of the Jekyll-Hyde nature of the planet - the contrast between day and night is a tad underplayed for my liking. But even if the script had allowed itself a bit more time to explore that, the main contrast that would have come to light (haha) would have been that shortfall between the excellent film sequences and the limited, too well lit studio scenes. It’s not an unforgiveable production flaw, but the difference is at least as stark as the film sequences are effective.

Luckily - for me anyway - imagination comes to the rescue and it’s easy enough to bridge the gap between what’s on screen and what we’d be seeing if this creative team had been granted more pennies.

In fact, courtesy of Pitch Black – another night-day split personality world if ever there was one – it’s even easier to imagine.

There’s further contrast to come between the earlier planet-based half and the later ship-bound action, with that second half of the story not quite as effective. Again, Roger Murray-Leach does a commendable job on the ship interiors – making simple but effective use of the third dimension and building his sets on more than one level – but ideally at this stage you’d need a greater variety of claustrophobic spaces and hunter-prey action to rival the haunting jungle atmosphere. Something a bit more Alien, perhaps, but again a charitable imagination can make allowances for the fact that this is 70s TV and not a late 70s blockbuster horror movie. And this is horror, make no bones about that. It doesn’t scare the living wotsits out of me now, but my childhood’s not so long ago that I’ve forgotten the effect the sight of those emaciated husks had at the time of broadcast. Terrific stuff, guaranteed to leave a lasting impression.

Ah, but the big budget remake would be to die for.

Or would it. Because, you know, it wouldn’t have Tom in such fine moody and flippant form. It wouldn’t have Lis Sladen in equally fine form, with all that Sarah Jane-Fourth Doctor chemistry out-frothing any Jekyll-Hyde formula. (And yes, shallowness fans, she also happens to be exceptionally cute.) It wouldn’t have Ewen Solon’s commanding (nothing second about it) performance as Vishinsky. Or Frederick Jaeger lending that all-important conviction to what amounts to the ‘mad scientist’ role in this one. In fact, he’s not mad, just a bit deluded and he creates a sympathetic character.

On the plus side, it wouldn’t have Prentis Hancock who plays Salamar who’s not so much at the top of the Morestran chain of command, but over it. It’s not the actor’s fault – although if you’ve seen him in Space:1999 or Who’s Planet Of The Daleks, you could be forgiven for thinking so. In contrast with Sorenson, the character is insane and unsympathetic, clinging obsessively to his suspicions of the Doctor and Sarah in the face of mounting evidence that, even without the aid of a CSI: Zeta Minor team, would safely eliminate beyond all reasonable doubt the remotest possibility of them having anything to do with the deaths.

The remaining crew are variable, but they include Michael Wisher – sans Davros mask – and there’s at least some passing effort made to sketch them as individuals before they all have the life sucked out of them.

And here is where I go off on a bit of tangent, because one of the things I was most struck by was just how much this story must have influenced my own Fourth Doctor novel, Drift. Lurking semi-invisible horror in remote, isolated location; spindly icicle tendrils instead of a (surprisingly effective) shimmering outline of a monster; and a military expedition whose personnel I endeavoured to properly characterise as individuals – real people – before they all got killed. (As always, a lot comes down to what’s planted in the imagination at the grand age of eight, rather than what’s actually on screen, but I could recognise the seeds.) In truth, there’s not a heck of a lot of evidence of the latter in the script, but the variety of actors help and I’m persuaded this is one of the stories that inspired me to adopt that approach.

With the sketchy references to the energy-starved Morestran civilization there are also hints of that wider world-building that Ian Potter explores in his essay for Time And Relative Dissertations In Time And Space. It would have been so easy to just make them a generic human expedition, but no, now we have Morestra – another world in the Doctor Who universe we’re free to visit in our imaginations.

Overall then, this is another of those stories that excites in terms of its possibilities as well as everything it paints on screen. And all the essential ingredients – according to yours truly’s recipe! – are present: something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue. Of course, there’s more than one way to mix them, and Planet Of Evil would certainly support the fact that it’s impossible to obtain perfect results every time. But I feel the parties responsible at least forged something that will last.

And they even managed to include a bit of foreshadowing, promising more borrowed wonders to come: Planet Of Evil, as an anagram of Vile Plant Foe, must surely be a reference to the season closer, six-part Triffids/Quatermass/The Thing From Another World ‘rip-off’, The Seeds Of Doom. Robert Holmes and Philip Hinchcliffe, such a clever pair.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

An Author By Any Other Name

In most respects I'm a modest kind of guy, but when it comes to writing I'd be the first to admit that one of the major buzzes to be had out of this business is seeing your book on the shelves at the local bookshop with your name on the cover. And yet here I am, only a few days after announcing the March release of The Shrieking Stones, my little foray into the world of Puffin under the name of Steve Rogers, and it turns out I've been commissioned to produce another pseudonymous work of children's fiction. Can't say anything more about it at this stage, obviously. Different genre, different pseudonym, different everything. But still me in disguise, so to speak. Never mind. As well as being modest I do like to share good news and celebrate, so: yay! :)

Monday, January 21, 2008

Familiarity Breeds... Daleks!

Genesis Of The Daleks poses a challenge, in that I’d be hard pressed to find anything new to say about it. It’s brilliant. And I’m pretty sure that will have been said before. For one thing, I used to think that and having watched it again over the past few days, I still do.

Fact is, I was afraid to watch it. It’s one of the Who stories I know very well. A little too well, I feared. It may have been the most-repeated story of the lot – it may not have been, but there were times it felt like it. I’m not sure when it was last repeated on BBC TV, but enough time must have lapsed since I’d last seen it, because although it was all very familiar, there wasn’t an ounce of contempt. I’d intended to watch an episode a day – as a sort of lunch-break treat. But I got through it a little faster than that because twice I caved and allowed myself “just one more”.

It’s not flawless – it’s Doctor Who. But it’s one of those “why don’t they make them like that any more?” stories. Well, we all know why: Mary Whitehouse won. We’re an audience of wusses and we certainly couldn’t let our children watch this sort of horrific material.

My parents let me watch it – I watched it with the family when I was seven – and yes it scared me. Woohoo! But it didn’t scar me. And boy, it fed my imagination. As we’ve already established, my imagination had already enjoyed a diet of giant maggots and spiders. Throw in the likes of Davros and of course it was bound to grow up strong.

This is a serial that revels in its darkness and is all the richer for it. The only thing that might make it darker is if it was lit like The West Wing. And now that I’ve said that, someone should really do a West Wing on Skaro, exposing the ins and outs of the Kaled corridors of power. As it is, we have corridors aplenty and the lighting helps paint a consistently claustrophobic atmosphere. Even the radioactive wastes of the Skaro No-Man’s Land is generally enclosed by smoke or fog.

The lighting only really gets it wrong at one point when it inadvertently allows us a glimpse of a very human-shaped head inside one of the Daleks. It’s a nit-pick and, like most nits, it’s not easy to catch – it surprised me, and I don’t recollect noticing it before. Who knows, maybe I did and forgave it, trundling swiftly on, along with the action.

Because, rather like The Green Death before it, this is a story that makes highly effective use of its six parts. Sure, it doesn’t have the breathless, almost desperate pace of some modern TV, but it strikes a terrific balance between keeping things moving and taking the proper time to explore its themes and situations. Allowing itself to breathe, while maintaining that wonderful claustrophobic atmosphere.

A couple of the cliffhangers aren’t as well-judged as The Green Death’s: Sarah plummeting to her death is a gasp out loud moment (certainly was when I was a nipper and had to wait a week to find out what happened to my favourite companion!), but the pay-off is weak – it needs Sevrin to lunge and grab her or something; and the Doctor being electrified is fair enough, but the sight of the Kaled dome being destroyed, when the Doctor knows he has sent Sarah and Harry into the holocaust, would have been a much more suspenseful moment for the break and considering it only comes all of two minutes into the next episode, I wonder why a trim wasn’t made here or there to accommodate that.

Still, in all honesty, it’d be difficult to know what to trim. Okay, we could afford to lose the giant clams. And we could afford to lose the image of the Doctor, Sarah and Harry flailing around in space at the end. But they’re the sort of flaws – again, nit picks – where we’d only want something else in their place. In the former case, the rejected experiments serve as a useful illustrator – a misstep in the – and I hesitate to use this phrase – evolution of the Daleks – as well as a decent slice of additional horror. A bit like the Slyther in Dalek Invasion Of Earth. In short, they didn’t have to be clams. And in the latter case, all we’d need is the same scene with a better visual – a warpy, swirly vortex effect or something not off the top of my head.

Ultimately though, it comes down to flaws shmaws. The nits, if you choose to pick them, are massively outweighed by the riches on offer. The best – blatant – use of WW2 imagery (uniforms and gas masks – and we all know how creepy those can be!) in sci-fi, pre-Star Wars – and, in any case, forget the Imperials, these Kaleds embrace the Nazi ideology and the ‘personality’ as well as the dress code. Peter Miles as Nyder, is exceptional, a brilliantly cold and memorable second to Davros himself. The Doctor agonising over the morality of genocide as he holds two wires an inch apart. Surely (one of?) the best hero-villain sit-down discussions ever (and obviously there’s going to be no wrestling over the Reichenbach Falls for these two – it wouldn’t be fair and wheelchair access is a bitch). Genuine shivers when Davros’ Dalek half boils over into the upper half and explodes out of him in a 'Fuhreristic' rant. He truly dominates, in the way all the supreme villains do.

At the time, I gather there was some disappointment that Davros hogged the action and the Daleks didn’t feature much. Well, d’uh. The fact that this was their creation story should have been a giveaway. In spite of that, the Daleks themselves make a significant stamp on the story – all the more effective, I think, because they are held in reserve – and when they do appear are more of a force to be feared and reckoned with. Apart from the regulars (naturally), they are the only characters in the piece whose future is assured. As they assert themselves, they will survive – and that is a powerful guarantee that lends them the commanding presence of a bona fide unstoppable force.

It’s not their fault they’re destined for a downhill slide after this.

And there lies the chief, significant problem with Genesis Of The Daleks. In terms of what followed, no Dalek story comes close. Even Davros – a supreme creation (who would have been eminently horrific even if I hadn’t had a grandmother who constantly reminded me of him) – becomes the elected representative of the law of diminishing returns. The mask is a cheap imitation of John Friedlander’s, the performances poorer cousins of Michael Wisher’s and the role steadily reduced to the dregs of what Terry Nation had cultivated. Their creation story should have granted them with a new lease of life, but instead their beginnings heralded a creative dead end. But the blame doesn’t rest on the shoulders of Genesis. That lies squarely with the writers/script editors/producers who couldn’t rise to the challenge laid down by this story: i.e. simply put, "Go on, do better than this, I dare ya."

Fortunately, its real legacy – the one that counts – is in the lasting impression it left on me and, probably, one or two others. And I’m glad to say, as familiar as the story is, that legacy is very much alive and well. And who knows what ideas I have, bubbling away in the incubation chamber of my imagination, that will ultimately owe their existence to this one monumental slice of Doctor Who from my childhood.